Skip to content

HONORING MILITARY WITH 15% OFF

Main Navigation

Sizzle Mastery: Grilling Filet Mignon at Home

Grilled filet mignon cuts over a grill with low fire

Greetings, aspiring grill aficianado! Ready to claim your throne as the sovereign of sizzling success? Embark on a quest towards grilling perfection that leaves your taste buds in awe and your dinner guests in envy.

The filet mignon – that prized cut that whispers tales of fine dining and luxury – is about to meet its match: you, armed with these ultimate steak BBQ secrets. Say adieu to the mediocre and hello to mouthwatering excellence.

Why Grilling Filet Mignon at Home Beats Steakhouse Dining

Picture this: the sizzle of steak as you lovingly tend to your grill, the aroma infusing your backyard with a scent better than any candle could offer. That's right, we're talking about the unmatched satisfaction of home-grilling advantages. Why settle for a steakhouse when your patio can be your personal sanctuary of meaty bliss?

The Rewards of Home-Cooked Luxury

Experiencing the art of perfecting steak at home isn't just for bragging rights—it's about crafting the experience you want. Every sizzle, every flip, every pinch of seasoning—it's all under your reign. The feel of that spatula handle in your hand? That's the scepter of a grill sovereign.

The Cost-Effective Choice for Fine Dining

Believe it when we say that your wallet will thank you for the saving on steakhouse bills. Summoning the courage to peek at a steakhouse check requires fortitude of the wallet—a challenge you can gracefully avoid. See, purchasing that juicy filet mignon from your local butcher not only supports local businesses, but frees you from the clutches of posh restaurant pricing.

Keys to Perfecting Filet Mignon In Your Own Kitchen

Looking to dazzle dinner guests or treat yourself to an unforgettable meal? Here's a tip: the key lies in the filet mignon home preparation. By selecting the finest cut, using a simple yet effective spice pantry, and applying that secret weapon—patience—you’re not just grilling; you’re crafting a masterpiece. 

Did you know that you can air fry filet mignons, too? It's a game-changer for steak lovers looking to enjoy a gourmet meal with minimal effort. Now let's get back to our grilling business.

Choosing the Right Cut: Selecting Premium Filet Mignon

Filet mignon cuts on paper towel over wood cutting board

 

Identifying Quality: What to Look For at the Butcher

Stride into your local butcher's domain with the confidence of a seasoned chef. First off, color is your ally in selecting filet mignon. Seek out a rich, charming ruby red that speaks to its quality and freshness. Give a gentle poke – if it springs back with enthusiasm, you're on the right track. Keep your eyes peeled for that smooth, velvety exterior; a surface marred by tough "silver skin" is a culinary foe you don't want on your grill.

Understanding Filet Mignon's Unique Texture and Taste

Here's the skinny: filet mignon hails from the tenderloin, and its reputation for a buttery texture isn't just foodie folklore. It's the truth, tender as a love song, and subtle in flavor, demanding a more refined palate to fully appreciate its understated elegance.

Prepare to pitch a premium price for such a prize cut, with tabs ranging from a cool $30 to an opulent $45 per pound.

Filet mignon is one of the most expensive steak cuts, but the rich, tender morsels it yields are worth every penny. It's the cut that 'melts in your mouth'.

Preparation Tips Before the Grill

This is it, the preamble to sizzle town. After preparing filet mignon, the stage should be impeccably set. Begin by liberating those steaks from the icy clutches of your refrigerator, allowing them to bask at room temperature.

The goal? To ensure an even cook through to the heart of the cut. And when it comes to seasoning, restrain your inner artist – a stately sprinkle of salt and pepper is all the canvas of a filet requires.

Seasoning Your Steak: The Pathway to Flavor

Let's cut to the chase—you're prepping a filet mignon and you want to knock the socks off your taste buds. Grab the best filet mignon seasoning, which, might I remind you, often involves nothing more than a liberal dash of salt and pepper. That's right, a simple steak seasoning is your ticket to culinary stardom. Now, what are you going to need to turn this beefy canvas into a masterpiece?

First things first: seasoning filet mignon. It's less about complexity and more about allowing those natural flavors to come forward like the lead singer in a rock band. A dual hit of salt and pepper, that's your frontman. But every rock star needs a good backup, and in this case, it's the basting trio of butter, rosemary, and garlic that plays rhythm guitar to your steak's chart-topping hit.

But don't stop there; consider this your grounds to experiment within the limits of these simple foundations. Remember, when you're working with a cut as prestigious as a filet mignon, it's not about dressing it up in every seasoning under the sun.

Focus on effective steak seasoning that respects and elevates the main event—the steak itself. Why not try our salt-free seasonings to add depth and refinement to your filet mignon?

The Essential Tools: Cast Iron and the Perfect Baste

Gearing up for the ultimate steak escapade, you might ask, "What alchemy of tools transforms a good steak into a gastronomic masterpiece?" Well, fear not. Cast iron skillets and a masterful baste are your culinary sidekicks in this flavorful quest.

Why Cast Iron Pans Make a Difference

Behold the cast iron skillet for steak, your trusty culinary compadour renowned for its stellar heat retention and durability. Leave wimpy cookware in the dust; when it comes to creating an emissary-worthy sear, nothing performs quite like cast iron. It's like giving your steak a sun-kissed tan that’s envy-worthy. Moreover, its even heat distribution ensures every square inch of your steak gets the love and browning it richly deserves.

Crafting a Flavorful Basting Butter

Now, take your taste buds for a spin with a homemade basting butter recipe that'll make your steak weep with joy. Combine unsalted butter, aromatic rosemary, and garlic to concoct an elixir so lush, even your spatula will want a lick. As you slather and baste, each brushstroke paints layers of flavors deeper than a philosopher's musings, ensuring a moist and tender steak that'll be the talk of your dinner table.

Filet mignon cuts on pan with butter

Alternatives for the Non-Cast Iron Owners

Feeling left out without a cast iron in your culinary arsenal? Worry not, the grilling world has not forsaken you. An oven-safe stainless steel pan can pick up the slack, offering a grilling without cast iron experience that can still result in a delectable crust. Although it might not wield the same might as cast iron, it's a commendable understudy when the show must go on.

Whether you’re flipping steaks with effective basting tools or experimenting with grilling techniques, keep your senses sharp and your palette ready. Now go forth, armed with your trusty tools and buttery artillery, and grill steaks worthy of legend.

Mastering the Sear: The First Step to Grilling Filet Mignon

Grill enthusiasts and carnivore connoisseurs, gather 'round: the quest for the perfect steak sear is not just about showing off those grill marks; it's about locking in that succulent tenderness of your filet mignon. Let's not mince words – a superb sear is the beefy badge of honor you want to achieve in your meaty endeavors, and it's the cornerstone of high-heat grilling. Your steak's destiny hinges on this: a crust of rich caramelization that tells tales of flavor deep within. So, how do you ensure the ultimate sear that'll make your taste buds swoon? It's all in the sizzle, smoke, and timing.

Before anything else, crank up that heat! Whether you're over charcoal's glow or a stove's blaze, ensure your cooking surface screams hot. This is not the time for lukewarm commitments – high-heat grilling demands boldness.

Hear that hiss? That's the sound of the surface of your steak enthusiastically embracing the pan. You've got two minutes. No flipping, no poking, no second-guessing. After those 120 seconds, flip it to impart equal opportunity for crust development on the flip side.

Remember: the filet edges are not to be neglected – tuck them into the pan for a minute's sear to ensure a 360-degree taste sensation.

Indeed, you're crafting a masterpiece with grilling techniques that straddle art and science. To that end, here's a concise sear schedule table to guide you on this flavorful journey:

  • Preheat pan to a sizzling temperature.
  • Lay steak down gently, searing without moving for 2 minutes.
  • Flip the steak and sear other side for another 2 minutes.
  • Sear edges for a total of 1 minute, rotating evenly.
  • Rest your masterpiece pre-sauce introduction for 5-10 minutes.

Stick to the script, and you shall have a filet mignon so impeccably seared it becomes the stuff of legend. Or at least, the talk of the dinner table. Here's to searing filet mignon so well that it’d earn a nod of respect from the pan itself, were it only sentient. Cheers, to your grilling triumph!

Grilling Filet Mignon Like a Pro

The moment has arrived; you stand ready to command the grill and ensure that your filet mignon is the envy of meat lovers everywhere. With an intuition for timing your steak grill and an understanding of heat zones for grilling, you're about to prove that you've mastered the artistry necessary for grilling filet mignon to perfection.

Grilling filet mignon cuts

The Art of Timing and Flipping for Perfect Doneness

Mastery of the grill is more than just about heat; it's a timed dance with precision. A medium-rare marvel or a well-done wonder, your filet mignon's fate hangs in the balance, beholden to your deft timing and skilled flipping. To keep track, use these steak doneness techniques and savor the anticipation of that first succulent bite—a reward well-earned for your vigilance.

Utilizing Heat Zones on the Grill

Every seasoned griller knows: no two spots on your grill are identical. Dividing your grill into heat zones enables correct cooking environments for optimal texture and flavor. The intense searing heat locks in the juices, while a milder zone allows your steak to cook through to your desired level without the threat of becoming charcoal's next victim. In these zones lies the secret to a filet mignon that whispers tales of charred exterior and tender, juicy interior to anyone lucky enough to partake in its glory.

Testing for Doneness: When to Pull Your Steak Off the Heat

Even the most experienced grill masters rely on tools to get it right. An instant-read thermometer is your trident in the open seas of grilling—guiding you to the shores of perfect doneness. Insert it into the thickest part of your steak; watch the numbers, not the clock, to determine when it's time to retire your filet mignon from the flames. It's not just a meal you're preparing—it's an edible sonnet.

Resting Your Meat: A Critical Yet Overlooked Step

It's a common sight: a beautifully seared steak coming hot off the grill and immediately being sliced into, only to find that the much-anticipated juiciness has fled the scene. Let's talk about the importance of resting steak, a showstopper that enters stage left after the grill has done its job. No, it's not nap time — it's when the magic really happens.

Skipping the rest is like sprinting a marathon and not taking a victory lap. Give your steak the rest it deserves and watch that juiciness level rise like a standing ovation.

Time for a quick dive into steak resting techniques. The rule of thumb: a 5 to 10-minute rest for every inch of thickness. Create a warm environment using a tent of foil, but don't wrap it up tight — think cozy blanket, not airtight seal.

Two grilled filet mignon resting on a wood cutting board
  • Place your steak on a warm plate or cutting board.
  • Gently cover with aluminum foil, creating a loose tent.
  • Resist the temptation to poke or prod; let the steak bask in its own glorious heat.
  • After the rest, cut across the grain for maximum tenderness.

Now, let's turn up the wit-meter. They say patience is a virtue, but in the world of steak cooking tips, it's a downright superpower. By resting your steak, you're transforming that sizzling cut into a juicy masterpiece, ensuring all the effort at the grill wasn't just a smoke show.

Remember, ensuring steak juiciness isn't about rushing to the finish line — it's about savoring the journey. Consider the rest as the encore to a perfectly grilled performance, the final bow where the flavors and textures receive their standing ovation.

Mastering the rest is what transforms the home cook into a grill guru. So, stick the landing with a solid rest, and indulge in the applause from your taste buds. They know when a show has been done right.

Side Dishes: Complementing Your Filet Mignon

When you’ve nailed that filet mignon, it’s time to frame it with the perfect gallery of side dishes. Think of your plate as a canvas, and you're the artist about to add splashes of color with vibrant veggies and strokes of indulgence with hearty starchy sides. Ready? Set your table for a feast that checks all the boxes of taste, texture, and eye appeal!

Pairing Vegetables for a Balanced Meal

Let's not skirt around the garden of delights; vegetables are your ally in this savory escapade. Balancing steak with veggies isn't just about nutrients; it’s about creating a refreshing contrast that makes every bite of that filet mignon feel like the first. Asparagus spears, with their tender yet crisp bite, make for an elegant sidekick. Or, if variety is your spice of life, imagine a medley of roasted vegetables, all caramelized edges and deep flavors—a cornucopia of colors on your plate.

Starchy Sides that Elevate Your Filet

Choosing starchy sides that complement your steak is like finding the right pair of shoes for your outfit—essential. Creamy mashed potatoes are a classic, but why not up the ante? Think golden-brown potato gratin, layered with cheese and herbs, or perhaps a side of risotto, each grain rich with the embrace of stock and parmesan. Starchy sides are your base note, laying down the harmony for the melody that is your perfectly grilled steak.

Sauces and Butters to Add Richness

Now, what about the high notes? The grand finale? That’s where sauces strut onto the stage. A velvety béarnaise, with its tarragon-infused elegance, or a red wine reduction, deep and complex, can elevate your steak from simply great to the realm of divine. Even a pat of compound butter, melting and mingling its herb laced decadence onto your steak, can be that little something extra that earns a standing ovation. After all, enhancing steak with sauces and butters is not just recommended—it’s a gustatory commandment.

filet mignon on a plate with side dishes

Now, behold the pantheon of side dishes in an organized spread that will make selecting your filet mignon's dinner companions as easy as pie (which, by the way, is a terrific idea for dessert).

Vegetable Sides Starchy Sides Sauces/Butters
Grilled Asparagus with Lemon Zest Truffled Mashed Potatoes Classic Béarnaise Sauce
Rainbow Roasted Vegetables Cheesy Potato Gratin Peppercorn Cream Sauce
Charred Brussels Sprouts Wild Mushroom Risotto Garlic Herb Compound Butter
Maple-Glazed Carrots Roasted Garlic Cauliflower Mash Red Wine Reduction
Spinach and Strawberry Salad Sweet Potato Fries Chimichurri Sauce

 

Leftover Filet Mignon: Storage and Reheating Methods

So, you've miraculously found yourself with leftover filet mignon, a stroke of luck as rare as a perfectly medium-cooked steak. Fear not; you're moments away from mastering the art of storing leftover steak to ensure that none of that decadent flavor is lost. Whether it's a sliver or a whole steak, preservation is key to enjoying your filet mignon in the forthcoming days or even months.

When it comes to storing your filet mignon in the fridge and freezer, the approach is simple but crucial for preserving the steak's quality. Follow these uncomplicated steps, and you'll secure the longevity of your leftover steak's succulence:

  • Allow the steak to cool to room temperature before storing it. No need to speed up this process; patience is a virtue that pays off.
  • Wrap it up snugly in aluminum foil or plastic wrap. Think of it as tucking in your meat for a short nap or a long hibernation.
  • For fridge storage, lovingly place it in the coolest part of your refrigerator, ensuring it enjoys a chilled respite for 4 to 5 delectable days.
  • If the freezer is your steak's destination, a heavy-duty freezer bag is your best ally for a trip up to three flavor-packed months.
Quick Tip: The thinner the slices, the better the experience upon revival.

Now, let's talk about reheating filet mignon. Whether you're hungering for a quick bite or planning a new meal entirely, preserving the luxurious essence of your leftover steak is nothing short of a sacred mission:

  1. Remove the steak from the fridge/freezer and allow it to approach room temperature for even reheating.
  2. Cue your microwave's gentlest setting, as high heat is to be avoided when reviving the spirit of a divine filet mignon.
  3. Check on your steak every 30 seconds, as it slowly warms up to its former glory.

Imagine taking a bite and being transported back to the moment of its initial, impeccable grilled perfection. Yes, that's what we're aiming for—a reheated revelation!

Leftover steak inside an aluminum foil

Remember, just because the grilling has ended doesn't mean the journey is over. With the right storage and reheating methods, you extend the life and luxury of your filet mignon, reaffirming your title as a connoisseur of fine meat management. Your leftovers will thank you, and your taste buds will cheer in a standing ovation. Encore!

FAQ

Can you break down the steps to grilling the perfect filet mignon?

Absolutely! Start by selecting a steak with a rich, red color and no tough silver skin. Let it reach room temperature before seasoning with salt and pepper. Preheat your pan—cast iron is preferred—until it's hot enough for a sizzling sear, about 2 minutes on one side, sear the edges for one minute, then flip. After searing, move it to the oven or a cooler part of the grill to finish cooking to your desired doneness. Let it rest before serving to ensure juiciness. Voilà!

How do I select the best cut of filet mignon at the butcher's shop?

Target a deep red hue, signaling top-notch quality. Softness to the touch indicates a tender texture. Avoid any steaks with that tough silvery membrane. Remember, you're looking for the tenderloin's MVP. It's the buttery texture and subtle flavor that make it worth its weight in gold—well, almost.

What kind of seasoning should I use for filet mignon?

Keep it simple, Sherlock. Salt and pepper are your dynamic duo here. Generously sprinkle them on and let the steak's inherent flavors steal the show. Trust me, simplicity is the ultimate sophistication here.

Is there an alternative to using a cast iron skillet for grilling filet mignon?

While a cast iron skillet is primo for that perfect sear, if you're without, an oven-safe stainless steel pan will pinch hit. Non-stick pans? They're riding the bench for this high-heat game.

How do I know when my steak is perfectly done?

This is where precision meets intuition. Sear, then use an instant-read thermometer religiously to check for doneness – 120°F for rare, 145°F for medium, and 160°F for well-done. Familiarize yourself with your grill's heat zones and flirt with the flames until it's just right.

Why do I need to let my steak rest, and for how long?

Don't just do something, stand there! Letting your steak rest for 5 to 10 minutes after grilling gives the juices a chance to redistribute, making sure every bite is as tender and juicy as you dreamed. Skipping this step is like skipping the encore of your favorite concert—just don't.

What are the best sides to serve with filet mignon?

Let your filet mignon be the rockstar and your sides the adoring fans. Pair it with something green – asparagus plays well – or go for the carb comfort of mashed potatoes. Sauce things up with béarnaise or a dollop of herby butter to really make that steak sing.

How do I properly store and reheat leftover filet mignon?

First, leftover steak? Who are you, and how did you resist finishing it? If you must, slice it up, store it in the fridge for a quick bite within 4 to 5 days, or give it a proper chill in the freezer for up to three months. Reheat it gently in the microwave or skillet, and that steak will be making a comeback tour.

Any tips for first-time grillers of filet mignon?

Take a deep breath, you've got this. Stick to a hot pan for searing, monitor the steak's internal temp like it's the stock market, and let it rest—it's not lazy; it's crucial. Also, have a backup plan. If your first steak is less than perfect, just call it a "practice round" and try again. Your grill master status is pending, not denied.

How can I bring a steakhouse quality experience to my home grilling?

Create the ambiance! Set the table nicely, get some classy tunes playing, and pour a glass of your favorite wine. With your newly honed skills in selecting, seasoning, and grilling filet mignon, you’re all set to rival the pros. Just remember, confidence in your skills is half the battle won—now go create that sizzle.

Conclusion

As the curtain falls on our filet mignon escapade, take a moment to bask in the glory of your newfound prowess. You've journeyed from eager novice to a champion of the char, mastering grilling filet mignon with a finesse that rivals any seasoned chef. Armed with the secrets of selecting the finest cuts, achieving the perfect sear, and letting those savory slices rest, you're not just cooking; you're creating art on the grill.

See Virginia Boys Kitchens On Amazon

We are on Amazon, see our storefront here. Use coupon code VBKBLOG10 for 10% off your entire purchase of any Virginia Boys Kitchens on Amazon. Apply the code at checkout.